When Retry On Fail is enabled, it only works as expected with the Stop Workflow option under On Error. Using it with Continue or Continue (using error output) leads to unexpected behavior.
Even if the node succeeds on a retry, the result is still marked as an error, and retries continue until the max number is reached. This happens even if the final attempt is successful.
If this behavior won’t be changed, it would be helpful to clearly explain which combinations are supported or not in the UI.
You can track the random number and whether it’s considered acceptable via the console log.